Newsroom Money and Tax
HMRC penalty appeal: how to challenge a fine
Opening a letter from HMRC and finding a penalty inside is a horrible feeling, and lots of owners pay it straight away without asking any questions. An HMRC penalty appeal can sometimes reduce or cancel the fine, if you have a good reason and the evidence to back it up. Lucy Johnson, the accountant behind Tax Made Simple, explains how in this video.
Video by Lucy Johnson at Tax Made Simple on YouTube. Well worth a subscribe.
What Lucy covers
- Penalties are mostly automated. Lucy says nobody usually reviews your case before the fine goes out, so mistakes happen.
- HMRC looks for a reasonable excuse. She lists serious illness, bereavement, HMRC system problems and HMRC’s own errors among the reasons it often accepts.
- Facts beat feelings. Lucy advises a short, clear timeline with evidence attached, such as a hospital letter.
- Act fast. According to Lucy, you usually have 30 days from the date of the penalty notice.
What makes an HMRC penalty appeal work
Lucy is clear that forgetting, being too busy or not having the money won’t usually count as a reasonable excuse. What HMRC wants is a clear account of what happened and when, plus proof.
She says the biggest mistake is sending an angry letter. Her example is much better. It gives the date you went into hospital, the date you came out, and a line saying the evidence is attached. Short and professional is what gets results.
Lucy also shares some appeals that worked. One client’s accountant had passed away unexpectedly, and HMRC accepted the appeal. Another owner was in hospital over a VAT deadline, and that penalty was cancelled.
She explains you can appeal online through your Government Gateway account, which is usually quickest, or by letter. If you write, she suggests keeping copies, sending it tracked and including your UTR and the penalty reference. Everyone’s situation is different, so check with your own accountant before you act on any of this.
Fix the system behind the late return
Lucy gives a fair warning too. An appeal isn’t guaranteed, and if you’re filing late every year, she says the answer is better systems. She mentions accounting software, calendar reminders and getting your accountant involved earlier.
This is where I see a big overlap with marketing. The owners who miss deadlines are usually doing every job in the business themselves, often late at night. When the admin piles up, the marketing tends to stop at the same time. A simple weekly routine for paperwork frees up your head for finding new customers.
An HMRC letter left unopened on the side only ever gets more expensive.
I’d put your filing deadlines in your phone today, with a reminder a month before each one. Keep one folder for HMRC letters, and open them the day they arrive. It takes a few minutes and saves a lot of worry.
If a penalty lands on your doormat, check whether you have a reasonable excuse before you pay it.
More from the blog
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to appeal an HMRC penalty?
Lucy says you usually have 30 days from the date on the penalty notice, so it’s best to act quickly and gather your evidence early.
What counts as a reasonable excuse for HMRC?
According to Lucy, HMRC often accepts serious illness, a bereavement near the deadline, HMRC system problems or HMRC’s own mistakes. Forgetting or being too busy won’t usually work.
Once the paperwork is under control, the next job is a steady flow of the right customers. Our full marketing team takes the marketing off your plate, so you have more time to run the business. Book a free strategy call and we will talk it through.











